| | | | | |
| 1970s | | 1980s | | 1990s | |
| 1974 | Dillon Wilson | 1980 | Andy Colby & Bobby Scruton | 1990 | Bruce Steinberg |
| 1975 | Tim Carberry | 1981 | Matt LeBlanc | 1991 | Adam Jackson & Robbie Anderson |
| 1976 | Doug Gaskell | 1982 | Paul Predaris | 1992 | Justin Hebert |
| 1977 | Bobby Severance | 1983 | Keith Duggan | 1993 | John Kennedy |
| 1978 | Carl Gallines | 1984 | Delton J. Record | 1994 | Lani Fortier & Spencer Hagstrom |
| 1979 | Tom Flanigan & Tom Brown | 1985 | Erik Jacksen | 1995 | Lindsey Chapman & Zach Piper |
| | 1986 | Brent Willey | 1996 | David Harris |
| | 1987 | Ryan Jackson | 1997 | Dan Sonneborn |
| | 1988 | Chad Woodman | 1998 | Casey Lockwood |
| | 1989 | Jason Sharp & Matt Cronin | 1999 | Aaron Whittet |
| | | | | |
| | | | | |
2000s | |
2010s | |
2020s | |
| 2000 | Casey Sullivan | 2010 | Charlie Kendall | 2020 | |
| 2001 | Kyle Losik | 2011 | Garret Husslage | 2021 | Ollie Lannon |
| 2002 | Adam Whitman | 2012 | Jack Reaney | 2022 | Derek Swartz |
| 2003 | John Mulvey | 2013 | Dylan King | 2023 | Liam Belden |
| 2004 | Austin Mikolaities | 2014 | Maddie Predaris | 2024 | Mac Stead |
| 2005 | Quinn McCann | 2015 | Luke Freeman | | |
| 2006 | Duncan Robinson | 2016 | Jack Wade | | |
| 2007 | Joe Richard | 2017 | Killian Gray | | |
| 2008 | Curran Sullivan | 2018 | Cade Murphy | | |
| 2009 | Carter King, Carter Madden & Xavier Quinn | 2019 | Gar Hindle | |